Geosynthetic categories compared.
Five geosynthetic categories cover most Malaysian geotechnical, infrastructure, and environmental applications: geogrid (uniaxial vs biaxial, PET vs PP), geotextile (woven vs nonwoven), geocell (HDPE 3D confinement), geomembrane (HDPE/LLDPE liner), and geocomposite (drainage panels combining multiple functions). Each performs a distinct function (reinforcement, filtration, separation, confinement, containment, drainage) and the polymer choice (PET, PP, HDPE) drives durability, creep behavior, and chemical resistance. This page compares each category with honest trade-offs. STRATA Geosystems product range is referenced where applicable, sole-distributed in Malaysia by Starwall Sdn Bhd. Designed to BS 8006, ISO 10319, ASTM D6637, D4491, D4716, JKR-SPJ.
Quick comparison matrix.
| Category | Primary function | Polymer | Strength / spec | Cost band (RM/m²) | STRATA product |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Geogrid (uniaxial) | Tension reinforcement, one direction | PET (woven/extruded) | 50-300 kN/m (ISO 10319) | 18-35 | StrataGrid SG200-SG800 |
| Geogrid (biaxial) | Tension + confinement, both directions | PP (integral) | 20-40 kN/m each direction | 12-22 | (Various brands) |
| Geotextile (woven) | Separation, filtration, moderate reinforcement | PP (slit film, monofilament) | 50-200 kN/m, AOS to BS EN ISO 12956 | 4-12 | StrataTex HSR |
| Geotextile (nonwoven) | Filtration, drainage, protection | PP (needle-punched) | 200-500 gsm typical, permittivity 0.5-2.0 s⁻¹ | 3-8 | (Various brands) |
| Geocell | 3D cellular confinement | HDPE (textured perforated) | Wall strength 18-25 kN/m, ASTM D5397 | 35-65 | StrataWeb |
| Geomembrane | Containment, liquid/gas barrier | HDPE / LLDPE | 1.0-2.5 mm thickness, ASTM D5994 | 14-28 | (Various brands) |
| Geocomposite drainage | In-plane drainage with built-in filter | HDPE core + PP filter | Transmissivity 0.5-3 L/s/m (ASTM D4716) | 65-130 | StrataDrain |
Cost bands are typical Malaysian indicative ranges supply-only per m². Installation labor adds 30-80 percent depending on application complexity. Always tender for project-specific delivery.
Function and mechanism, by category.
Geogrid (uniaxial PET, StrataGrid)
Polyester (PET) yarns drawn into a high-tenacity grid with apertures sized for soil interlock (typically 25-35 mm). Strength is in the machine direction (load-bearing roll length). PET is creep-resistant and chemically inert across pH 4-10. Used for tension reinforcement in MSE walls, modular block walls, reinforced soil slopes (RSS), and basal reinforcement of embankments over soft ground. Tensile strength tested per ISO 10319 (wide-width) or ASTM D6637 (single rib). Long-term design strength accounts for creep (typically 15-30 percent of ultimate) per ISO 13431.
Function: reinforcement. Typical use: MSE wall, RSS, basal reinforcement, segmental block wall.
Geogrid (biaxial PP)
Polypropylene (PP) sheet stretched in both machine and cross directions to form integrally-formed grid. Equal strength in both directions, but lower than uniaxial PET (typically 20-40 kN/m each way vs 50-300 kN/m for uniaxial). Used for pavement subgrade reinforcement, working platform on soft ground, base course reinforcement under flexible pavement. PP has lower creep resistance than PET, suitable for short-term loading or where PET cost is prohibitive.
Function: reinforcement + lateral confinement. Typical use: pavement, working platform, soft-ground base course.
Geotextile (woven, StrataTex HSR)
PP slit-film or monofilament yarns woven into a continuous fabric. High tensile strength (50-200 kN/m) and good filtration through controlled apparent opening size (AOS to BS EN ISO 12956). Used as separator under road base, filter behind drainage systems, moderate reinforcement, and erosion control underlayer. Permittivity (cross-plane flow) is moderate compared to nonwoven.
Function: separation, filtration, moderate reinforcement. Typical use: road subgrade separator, French drain wrap, riprap underlayer.
Geotextile (nonwoven)
PP fibers needle-punched into a felt-like fabric. Lower tensile strength (5-25 kN/m) but high permittivity (water flows through readily) and good filtration via thickness. Used as filter wrap for drainage pipes, protection layer under geomembrane (puncture protection), erosion control fabric. Mass per unit area typically 200-500 gsm.
Function: filtration, drainage, protection. Typical use: French drain wrap, geomembrane cushion, erosion control.
Geocell (StrataWeb HDPE)
HDPE strips ultrasonically welded into a honeycomb of cells (typical 100-300 mm cell diameter, 75-200 mm depth). When stretched open and filled with soil/aggregate, the cellular confinement laterally restrains fill, increases load-bearing capacity, and prevents shallow erosion. Perforated walls allow lateral hydraulic connection. HDPE 75-120 year design life, stress-crack resistance per ASTM D5397.
Function: 3D confinement. Typical use: steep slope vegetated facing, load support over soft ground, channel protection, working platform.
Geomembrane (HDPE / LLDPE)
Continuous polymer sheet (HDPE for stiffness, LLDPE for flexibility), typical 1.0-2.5 mm thick, low-permeability barrier (< 1×10⁻¹⁴ m/s). Used for liquid containment (landfill liner, pond liner, dam face), gas containment (landfill cap), and chemical barrier. Welded at panel seams (extrusion welding, hot wedge). Tested per ASTM D5994 (thickness), D5397 (stress crack), D4885 (hydrostatic resistance).
Function: containment / barrier. Typical use: landfill liner/cap, pond, dam face, chemical containment.
Geocomposite drainage (StrataDrain)
3D HDPE drainage core sandwiched between PP geotextile filter on one or both faces. Replaces traditional gravel-and-pipe drainage layer. In-plane transmissivity tested per ASTM D4716, typically 0.5-3 L/s per m width depending on core thickness and gradient. Used behind retaining walls, MSE walls, basements, bridge abutments, under pavements, behind landfill liners.
Function: in-plane drainage with integrated filter. Typical use: retaining wall back drain, basement perimeter, MSE wall back drain, abutment drainage.
Why polymer matters: PET vs PP vs HDPE.
| Polymer | Strength behavior | Creep resistance | UV resistance | Chemical range | Design life | Typical category |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| PET (polyester) | High tensile strength, low elongation | Excellent (15-30 percent creep factor) | Moderate (UV protection coating used) | pH 4-10 (avoid strong alkali) | 100-120 years | Uniaxial geogrid (StrataGrid) |
| PP (polypropylene) | Moderate strength, moderate elongation | Moderate (25-40 percent creep factor) | Moderate (UV stabilizer in formulation) | pH 1-13 (broad) | 50-75 years (subsurface) | Biaxial geogrid, geotextile (woven and nonwoven) |
| HDPE (high-density polyethylene) | Stiff, low elongation | Excellent (when low-stress) | Excellent (carbon black formulation) | pH 1-14 (very broad) | 75-120 years | Geocell (StrataWeb), geomembrane, geocomposite core (StrataDrain) |
| LLDPE | Flexible, higher elongation than HDPE | Good | Good | pH 1-14 | 50-75 years | Flexible geomembrane |
Rule of thumb: PET for permanent reinforcement (low creep). PP for filtration, separation, short-term reinforcement (cost-effective). HDPE for confinement and containment (chemical durability, dimensional stability). LLDPE where flexibility over irregular subgrade matters.
The honest trade-offs.
Uniaxial geogrid (PET) , pros
Highest tensile strength category (50-300 kN/m). Lowest creep, suitable for 100+ year MSE wall and RSS design. Mature design tradition (BS 8006, FHWA-NHI-10-024). StrataGrid available in full strength range from Starwall.
Uniaxial geogrid (PET) , cons
Avoid strong alkali (pH > 10) without protective measures. UV requires coating during exposure. Highest cost geosynthetic per unit area in this list (RM 18-35/m²).
Biaxial geogrid (PP) , pros
Cost-effective for pavement subgrade and working platform. Two-direction strength. Lower cost than PET (RM 12-22/m²). Broad chemical range.
Biaxial geogrid (PP) , cons
Lower strength than uniaxial PET. Higher creep, not suitable for permanent MSE wall reinforcement at 100+ year design life. PP UV degradation requires backfill within 14-30 days.
Woven geotextile (StrataTex HSR) , pros
Combines moderate reinforcement with separation and filtration. Highest tensile strength among geotextiles (50-200 kN/m). Lowest cost reinforcement geosynthetic (RM 4-12/m²). Robust for road base separator and riprap underlayer.
Woven geotextile , cons
Lower permittivity than nonwoven, cross-plane flow is moderate. Slit-film fibers can flatten under load, reducing flow over time. Not the right choice for primary filtration where water flow is the dominant function.
Nonwoven geotextile , pros
Best filtration and drainage permittivity. Cushion protection for geomembranes. Cheapest geotextile category (RM 3-8/m²). Fast install (rolled out, lapped).
Nonwoven geotextile , cons
Low tensile strength, no reinforcement role. Damage during construction (vehicle pass-through, mechanical placement) requires careful handling.
Geocell (StrataWeb) , pros
3D confinement is unique among geosynthetics. Holds steep vegetated slope faces (up to 1V:0.3H). Improves load-bearing on soft ground. HDPE 75-120 year life. Sole-distributed in Malaysia by Starwall.
Geocell , cons
Higher cost than geogrid (RM 35-65/m²). Requires fill and labor to deploy (set, anchor, fill cells). Not a tension reinforcement, choose geogrid if pure tension is the function.
Geomembrane (HDPE/LLDPE) , pros
Liquid and gas-tight (< 1×10⁻¹⁴ m/s). Required for landfill, pond, chemical containment by regulation. Long design life (50-100 years). Welded panels create continuous barrier.
Geomembrane , cons
Puncture risk requires nonwoven cushion under and over. Requires welder operator certification. Inspection of every weld seam (vacuum box test or dual-track air test). Specialized application.
Geocomposite (StrataDrain) , pros
Replaces gravel chimney drain, 90 percent thinner. Faster install (200-400 m²/day). Manufactured flow capacity certified to ASTM D4716. HDPE core durable. Sole-distributed by Starwall.
Geocomposite , cons
Higher per-m² cost than basic geotextile. Requires proper outlet detailing to deliver design flow. Mechanical damage during backfill placement requires care to avoid puncturing the geotextile face.
Decision-making conclusion.
| Use case | First choice | Avoid | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|
| MSE wall, 8-25 m, permanent infrastructure | Uniaxial PET geogrid (StrataGrid) | Biaxial PP, woven geotextile | PET creep resistance is the design driver. Higher strength range needed. |
| Modular block wall, 4-12 m, residential | Uniaxial PET geogrid (StrataGrid SG200-SG400) | Biaxial PP | PET 100+ year life needed for permanent residential structure. |
| Reinforced soil slope (RSS), 8-15 m | Uniaxial PET geogrid | Biaxial PP | Same as MSE wall, high tensile single direction. |
| Pavement subgrade reinforcement | Biaxial PP geogrid + woven geotextile separator | Uniaxial PET (over-engineered) | Two-direction confinement under traffic load. Cheaper polymer suitable here. |
| Working platform on soft ground | Biaxial geogrid + woven geotextile | Uniaxial alone | Two-direction strength matches construction load distribution. |
| French drain filter wrap | Nonwoven geotextile | Woven geotextile (lower permittivity) | Filtration is the function, choose nonwoven for permittivity. |
| Riprap underlayer | Woven geotextile (StrataTex HSR) | Nonwoven (lower puncture resistance) | Stone placement requires puncture-resistant high-strength fabric. |
| Steep slope vegetated face, 1V:0.5H, 8-15 m | Geocell (StrataWeb) | Geogrid (no confinement) | 3D confinement holds topsoil and grass on steep face. |
| Landfill liner / cap | HDPE geomembrane + nonwoven cushion + geocomposite drain | Single-layer anything | Regulatory compliance (DOE/JAS) requires multi-layer system. |
| Behind retaining wall, drainage | Geocomposite (StrataDrain) | Gravel chimney (slower install, more material) | Geocomposite cuts material and labor for same drainage capacity. |
| Pond / dam face | HDPE or LLDPE geomembrane + nonwoven cushion | Compacted clay alone (regulatory) | Geomembrane provides certified barrier, regulatory accepted. |
| Erosion control on slope | Coir mat (short-term) or geocell vegetated (long-term) | Pure geogrid (no erosion function) | Surface erosion needs cellular or fabric protection, not reinforcement. |
Codes for design and submission.
| Standard | Coverage |
|---|---|
| ISO 10319 | Geosynthetic wide-width tensile test (geogrid, geotextile) |
| ISO 13431 | Geosynthetic tensile creep, long-term reinforcement design strength |
| ASTM D6637 | Geogrid single rib or junction tensile strength |
| ASTM D4595 | Geotextile wide-width tensile strength |
| ASTM D4491 | Geotextile permittivity (cross-plane flow) |
| ASTM D4716 | Geocomposite transmissivity (in-plane flow) |
| ASTM D5994 | HDPE thickness for geomembrane and geocell |
| ASTM D5397 | HDPE single-point notched stress crack resistance |
| ASTM D5199 | Geosynthetic thickness measurement |
| BS 8006-1, 8006-2 | Strengthened/reinforced soils, design with geogrid and geotextile |
| BS EN 13252 | Geotextile filter, drainage characteristics required |
| FHWA-NHI-10-024 | MSE wall and reinforced soil slope design (geogrid, geotextile reinforcement) |
| FHWA-NHI-14-007 | Soil nail walls (where shotcrete face combines with geogrid in some designs) |
| JKR-SPJ Section 7 | Slope and earthwork specifications, Malaysian government works |
| NCMA SRW Design Manual | Segmental retaining wall design (modular block + geogrid) |
Selection and detailing remain the consulting C&S, geotechnical, or environmental engineer's responsibility for design submission to authority (MBPP, DBKL, MBPJ, MBSA, MBSJ, MPSJ, MPS, JKR Cawangan, Department of Environment for landfill/pond). We deliver to the consultant's drawing.
Engineers and developers usually ask:
Geogrid vs geotextile? +
Uniaxial vs biaxial geogrid? +
What is geocell and why use it? +
Typical cost? +
Standards? +
Related comparison resources.
Geosynthetics overview →
Full STRATA Geosystems product range overview.
Read moreGeogrid (StrataGrid) →
Uniaxial PET geogrid for MSE wall, modular block, RSS, basal reinforcement.
Read moreGeotextile (StrataTex) →
Woven separator, filter, and reinforcement fabric.
Read moreGeocell (StrataWeb) →
HDPE 3D cellular confinement.
Read moreGeomembrane →
HDPE/LLDPE liner for landfill, pond, chemical containment.
Read moreSTRATA Malaysia (via Starwall) →
Sole distributor of full STRATA Geosystems product range.
Read moreSpecifying geosynthetics and weighing categories?
Send the project parameters (function, design life, polymer constraints, structural loads, regulatory requirements). Same-day response with category recommendation, indicative budget, and reference to the relevant Malaysian/international standard.